‘Not enough were killed’

Councillor’s alleged comment on Maori sparks conduct review.

Councillor’s alleged comment on Maori sparks conduct review.

Two Gisborne district councillors are facing a code of conduct review after one alleged the other said "not enough" local Maori were killed by crew of the Endeavour.

Councillor Meredith Akuhata-Brown said during a lunchtime discussion one of her colleagues said to another "not enough were killed", referring to when local Maori were killed by crew of the Endeavour in October 1769.

Ms Akuhata-Brown made the accusation in a Gisborne Herald column this week, reflecting on a trip to Los Angeles with a group of students who had been learning about racism and tolerance.

"I returned home to a meeting with some Gisborne residents who feel at risk from our prisoner reintegration system, and a Gisborne District Council meeting where conversation over lunch included references to the killing of local Maori when Cook arrived, and according to a couple of my colleagues, 'not enough were killed'," she wrote.

"We still have a way to go when it comes to tolerance and understanding and yet some would say we have had better education, so why do such strong attitudes exist?"

The alleged comment referred to the first meeting between the crew of the Endeavour and Maori at Turanganui-a-Kiwa/Gisborne in October 1769, when nine Maori were shot and killed, and three young boys kidnapped.

Pressure has been mounting in the Gisborne community for the councillor who allegedly made the comment to come forward or be named, as Akuhata-Brown did not name them in her column.

Deputy mayor and chair of the code of conduct committee Rehette Stoltz said both the councillor who allegedly made the comment and Ms Akuhata-Brown were facing a code of conduct review.

"As signatories to our code of conduct we expect our elected members to act with the utmost integrity and respect in any forum in which they participate," Mrs Stoltz said.

"We will be working through a process to determine whether the principles of our code of conduct have been breached.

"I am disappointed with what has happened here and any breach will be dealt with swiftly and accordingly."

Ms Akuhata-Brown declined to comment, citing the code of conduct review.​

Two Gisborne district councillors are facing a code of conduct review after one alleged the other said "not enough" local Maori were killed by crew of the Endeavour.

Councillor Meredith Akuhata-Brown said during a lunchtime discussion one of her colleagues said to another "not enough were killed", referring to when local Maori were killed by crew of the Endeavour in October 1769.

Ms Akuhata-Brown made the accusation in a Gisborne Herald column this week, reflecting on a trip to Los Angeles with a group of students who had been learning about racism and tolerance.

"I returned home to a meeting with some Gisborne residents who feel at risk from our prisoner reintegration system, and a Gisborne District Council meeting where conversation over lunch included references to the killing of local Maori when Cook arrived, and according to a couple of my colleagues, 'not enough were killed'," she wrote.

"We still have a way to go when it comes to tolerance and understanding and yet some would say we have had better education, so why do such strong attitudes exist?"

The alleged comment referred to the first meeting between the crew of the Endeavour and Maori at Turanganui-a-Kiwa/Gisborne in October 1769, when nine Maori were shot and killed, and three young boys kidnapped.

Pressure has been mounting in the Gisborne community for the councillor who allegedly made the comment to come forward or be named, as Akuhata-Brown did not name them in her column.

Deputy mayor and chair of the code of conduct committee Rehette Stoltz said both the councillor who allegedly made the comment and Ms Akuhata-Brown were facing a code of conduct review.

"As signatories to our code of conduct we expect our elected members to act with the utmost integrity and respect in any forum in which they participate," Mrs Stoltz said.

"We will be working through a process to determine whether the principles of our code of conduct have been breached.

"I am disappointed with what has happened here and any breach will be dealt with swiftly and accordingly."

Ms Akuhata-Brown declined to comment, citing the code of conduct review.​

Your email address will not be published. Comments will display after being approved by a staff member. Comments may be edited for clarity.

Neil, Auckland - 1 month ago
I am sure that if the boot was on the other foot, a comment or opinion about "not enough being killed" would have been shrugged off and not "offended" anyone (of any significance). What I mean by that is that it is OK to deride some groups. And it would be OK if "code of conduct" cut both ways, but as we all know, it does not. Some of the "suppressed" history of this country, where there were mass killings of settlers by Maori, should be more widely reported. That would open some eyes and place perspective on the "comment".

lloyd gretton - 1 month ago
Most of these tragic deaths happened in the open sea. The deaths on the shore were self defence. But you can't expect a New Zealand reporter or his editor to be bothered with historical niceties. Nasty white people killed brown people.
In Cebu Cebu, Philippines, there is a statue on the shore to chief Cebu Cebu who killed Magellan, the first round-the-world explorer. Across the sea, there is a statue on the shore in Chile to Magellan. Chile is a modern country.
True, Philippines has more fun.

Poll

  • Voting please wait...
    Your vote has been cast. Reloading page...
    ​Do you think Gladstone Road Bridge should have its concrete parapet walls converted to steel railings on one or both of its sides as part of the upgrade and widening under way?

    See also:

    Opinion: