Rodeo ‘cover-up’ denied

Rodeo bosses have slammed claims from animal welfare groups of a cover-up over the death of a horse at the recent Gisborne rodeo.

A bull had to be put down during last month’s Gisborne event and anti-rodeo groups yesterday said the death of a horse had also occurred and subsequently been “covered up”.

New Zealand Rodeo Cowboys Association (NZRCA) president Lyal Cocks said that was not the case.

“A horse died in the stockyards at the Gisborne Rodeo as a result of an accident,” he said.

“The details of the accident are included in the NZRCA’s report to MPI (Ministry for Primary Industries).

“While any accident involving stock is regretted and saddens all rodeo members, this unusual accident away from the competition could have happened in any stock yards or paddock anywhere in the country and would not be news.

“The NZRCA has, understandably, become cautious speaking out in an environment of extreme negativity towards rodeos, which appears to be promoted by most media organisations.”

Animal rights and welfare organisation SAFE yesterday said it had obtained information that revealed a second animal was killed, “showing a lack of transparency around the animal cruelty in the rodeo community”.

“A source from the rodeo community, who wishes to remain anonymous, has informed SAFE that a horse was killed at the Gisborne Rodeo on December 27 after escaping a chute and running into a fence,” SAFE head of campaigns Marianne Macdonald said.

“This was the same rodeo where a bull was shot after dislocating part of his leg in a bull ride event.

“There’s no transparency or accountability at rodeo events. It requires whistle-blowers and activists to bring fatalities to the public’s attention, so we don’t know how many animals overall are killed by the rodeo cowboys.”

The Rodeo Code of Welfare covers animals used in rodeo events, as well as animals used in rodeo training and rodeo schools.

However, there are no requirements to report publicly on animal deaths and injuries.

“We know at least four animals have died in rodeo in 2018 but we don’t know how many have died in training. This figure could be so much bigger,” Ms Macdonald said.

Anti Rodeo Action NZ’s spokeswoman Lynn Charlton called for an immediate ban on rodeos, ahead of the Wairoa rodeo on January 19.

“We expect the Government and all farmers to be very concerned about what rodeo is doing to our international image.

“If you’re relying on farming for your income, you’d better hope the Government puts an end to rodeo, and quick smart.

“Terrorising and assaulting animals for entertainment is not acceptable to New Zealanders, and it would certainly be unacceptable to our trading partners.

“That some of these deaths are covered up to hide them from public outcry makes it all the more urgent to ban rodeo now.”

Rodeo bosses have slammed claims from animal welfare groups of a cover-up over the death of a horse at the recent Gisborne rodeo.

A bull had to be put down during last month’s Gisborne event and anti-rodeo groups yesterday said the death of a horse had also occurred and subsequently been “covered up”.

New Zealand Rodeo Cowboys Association (NZRCA) president Lyal Cocks said that was not the case.

“A horse died in the stockyards at the Gisborne Rodeo as a result of an accident,” he said.

“The details of the accident are included in the NZRCA’s report to MPI (Ministry for Primary Industries).

“While any accident involving stock is regretted and saddens all rodeo members, this unusual accident away from the competition could have happened in any stock yards or paddock anywhere in the country and would not be news.

“The NZRCA has, understandably, become cautious speaking out in an environment of extreme negativity towards rodeos, which appears to be promoted by most media organisations.”

Animal rights and welfare organisation SAFE yesterday said it had obtained information that revealed a second animal was killed, “showing a lack of transparency around the animal cruelty in the rodeo community”.

“A source from the rodeo community, who wishes to remain anonymous, has informed SAFE that a horse was killed at the Gisborne Rodeo on December 27 after escaping a chute and running into a fence,” SAFE head of campaigns Marianne Macdonald said.

“This was the same rodeo where a bull was shot after dislocating part of his leg in a bull ride event.

“There’s no transparency or accountability at rodeo events. It requires whistle-blowers and activists to bring fatalities to the public’s attention, so we don’t know how many animals overall are killed by the rodeo cowboys.”

The Rodeo Code of Welfare covers animals used in rodeo events, as well as animals used in rodeo training and rodeo schools.

However, there are no requirements to report publicly on animal deaths and injuries.

“We know at least four animals have died in rodeo in 2018 but we don’t know how many have died in training. This figure could be so much bigger,” Ms Macdonald said.

Anti Rodeo Action NZ’s spokeswoman Lynn Charlton called for an immediate ban on rodeos, ahead of the Wairoa rodeo on January 19.

“We expect the Government and all farmers to be very concerned about what rodeo is doing to our international image.

“If you’re relying on farming for your income, you’d better hope the Government puts an end to rodeo, and quick smart.

“Terrorising and assaulting animals for entertainment is not acceptable to New Zealanders, and it would certainly be unacceptable to our trading partners.

“That some of these deaths are covered up to hide them from public outcry makes it all the more urgent to ban rodeo now.”

Your email address will not be published. Comments will display after being approved by a staff member. Comments may be edited for clarity.

winston moreton - 5 months ago
Hope TGH follows up the NZRCA's report to MPI so the public can make its own assessment of the "unusual accidental death".

Steve Hindi, Illinois - 5 months ago
I am part of an organization that has investigated and exposed rodeo animal abuse across the United States for 25 years. I have personally investigated hundreds of rodeos. The rodeo industry's most closely held secret is the number of animals injured and killed.

Rodeo injury and death reports are not made public. There is every reason to believe that rodeos in New Zealand also cover up animal casualties, because the abuse and cruelty is the same.

If the public and sponsors knew the true cost to the animals, rodeos would be swept into the dustbin of history - which is where they belong.

Lizz Crawford - 5 months ago
Has there been a comparison between rodeo and non-rodeo animal deaths and injuries?

Poll

  • Voting please wait...
    Your vote has been cast. Reloading page...
    Do you want the rail line to Gisborne reinstated now?