Rail proponents in the clouds

LETTER

Re: Bold vision required, August 30 letter.

It is no good being disappointed with my comments. Having a vision, in this case, is having your head in the clouds.

I wrote it would take about seven years to open the line. Now let’s add on your idea, re-route the line if necessary, there goes another year at least. Plus you won’t find any stable ground. That is why there is trouble with the road. The engineers can’t get a stable base.

So, Robert, as I said, get a busload. October will be fine. Walk from Blacks Beach rail bridge to Waikokopu wharf. You may change your thinking. You may change your vision.

I don’t know if you know millions are being spent on crash rails from Gisborne to Napier. Shouldn’t that be used on road maintenance first?

My opinion is pour money into the road, you can’t do both rail and road.

As you say, you would think our engineers would be able to plan and have something stable built in this age.

I have always wondered why the Gisborne Rail Action Group didn’t get the line opened with a turntable up at Beach Loop for the steam engine to run. Looks like that is lost to railbikes.

Opening the line would be great. I have still got memories of travelling the line from the sixties. I still have memories of the railcar and freight trains going past our gate, and I didn’t mind being woken at night.

Merv Goodley

I have been a rail supporter since the original washout and couldn’t understand why the original BERL report was disregarded.

Of all the letters against the reinstatement, Merv Goodley’s are the only ones which seem to be supported by rational analysis instead of incorrect assumptions.

I am hoping he is wrong and the latest BERL report will settle once and for all the benefits — economic, social and environmental — of reinstating rail.

I also hope it will not be swept under the carpet as the last one was.

DJ Arthur

Re: Bold vision required, August 30 letter.

It is no good being disappointed with my comments. Having a vision, in this case, is having your head in the clouds.

I wrote it would take about seven years to open the line. Now let’s add on your idea, re-route the line if necessary, there goes another year at least. Plus you won’t find any stable ground. That is why there is trouble with the road. The engineers can’t get a stable base.

So, Robert, as I said, get a busload. October will be fine. Walk from Blacks Beach rail bridge to Waikokopu wharf. You may change your thinking. You may change your vision.

I don’t know if you know millions are being spent on crash rails from Gisborne to Napier. Shouldn’t that be used on road maintenance first?

My opinion is pour money into the road, you can’t do both rail and road.

As you say, you would think our engineers would be able to plan and have something stable built in this age.

I have always wondered why the Gisborne Rail Action Group didn’t get the line opened with a turntable up at Beach Loop for the steam engine to run. Looks like that is lost to railbikes.

Opening the line would be great. I have still got memories of travelling the line from the sixties. I still have memories of the railcar and freight trains going past our gate, and I didn’t mind being woken at night.

Merv Goodley

I have been a rail supporter since the original washout and couldn’t understand why the original BERL report was disregarded.

Of all the letters against the reinstatement, Merv Goodley’s are the only ones which seem to be supported by rational analysis instead of incorrect assumptions.

I am hoping he is wrong and the latest BERL report will settle once and for all the benefits — economic, social and environmental — of reinstating rail.

I also hope it will not be swept under the carpet as the last one was.

DJ Arthur

Your email address will not be published. Comments will display after being approved by a staff member. Comments may be edited for clarity.

W Gerrard, Australia - 10 days ago
Rail is part of infrastructure and should have money spent on it. Other countries have kept there rail, why not New Zealand? Why just spend money on roads, and who are these engineers who can't find stable land?

Phil Hunt, Picton - 6 days ago
If you see what has been done on the Kaikoura Coast (road and rail) you will see it is possible to reinstate over much more unstable ground. Yes! It is a vital link and had to be done, but the engineers won a UK award recently, the first time it had ever been awarded overseas.
We have travelled over both road and rail several times, not all is finished, but when it is it will actually be a better journey on either, as they were able to alter the routes slightly and incorporate a cycle/walkway for part of the way.

Poll

  • Voting please wait...
    Your vote has been cast. Reloading page...
    Are you pleased that New Zealand history will be taught in all schools and kura from 2022?