Concerns about impact of Meng Foon’s illegal seawall

An unconsented Gisborne seawall which defied council instruction has raised concern about potential impacts to the environment.

On October 6, Gisborne District Council issued an abatement notice to former mayor Meng Foon for work he had undertaken next to Tatapouri Bay Oceanside Accommodation, which he owns with wife Ying.

Foon began constructing the seawall  in front of the campground on August 25, and continued for several weeks after initially being asked to stop on August 31.

He cited erosion from Cyclone Gabrielle as a key driver for the project, and said the work was important to protect two large at-risk trees.

It followed a request to the council for post-cyclone funding which was never responded to, he said, although the organisation has refuted this.

Mr Foon also claimed the wall was within 10 metres of his surveyed boundary.

Craig Miller is a regular user of the boat ramp at Tatapouri, and alerted the council to the wall after he found out about it.

Miller — a former club captain of Gisborne Tatapouri Sports Fishing Club — said he could understand Foon’s desire to construct it, but was concerned about potential environmental fallout from the build.

“The biggest concern for us . . . is that we don’t know what effect him building a wall is going to have on the foreshore out there, when we are having big storm surges and so forth.

“Fine if you want to build a wall, just do it legally.”

Mr Miller wants the council to undertake an environmental impact report on the works, including potential impact to both the boat ramp and nearby Māori land.

He was also open to the idea that the wall could have a positive effect, which he said would be “great”.

“But we’re still back to the fact that Meng should have had a resource consent to do it.”

Mr Miller disagreed the works were a direct result of the cyclone, saying the disintegration at Tatapouri had occurred over a long period of time.

“That erosion all along that bank hasn’t happened since Gabrielle. That’s been happening slowly over the last 30 years .”

Last week, Mr Foon told Local Democracy Reporting he had advised Te Rūnanganui o Ngāti Porou about the project, along with adjacent Māori landowners Pouawa A1.

Gisborne District Council would not respond to questions about erosion, site boundaries or the potential for an environmental impact report, because of the ongoing investigation.

But an aerial map provided by Mr Foon shows his property boundary does extend on to the foreshore.

Meng Foon was mayor of Gisborne for 18 years from 2001 to 2019.